Q&A: “Shameless” vs “shameful”

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp
Share on email
Share on print

Each week here at the Australian Writers’ Centre, we dissect and discuss, contort and retort, ask and gasp at the English language and all its rules, regulations and ridiculousness. It’s a celebration of language, masquerading as a passive-aggressive whinge about words and weirdness. This week, shame on you…

Q: Hi AWC, can we talk about “shameless”?

A: Oh, do you mean that US comedy series starring William H Macy?

Q: I do not.

A: What a shame…

Q: I’d like to know how you can call something or someone “shameless” and it can somehow mean the same thing as “shameful”? Words like that usually mean opposite things – like “harmless” and “harmful”…

A: Yeah, English likes to keep us on our toes from time to time.

Q: English knows no shame!

A: Or in this case, it appears to know quite a few. The word “shame” was around in Old English way back in the 13th century, originally “scamu”.

Q: Oh, so is the word “scam” related to it then?

A: No. “Scam” in fact wasn’t seen until 1963 – likely influenced by 18th and 19th century “scamp”, meaning a cheater or robber.

Q: Fair enough.

A: However, from that original Old English “scamu” we got the original spelling of “scamless” and “scamful”. And both words initially related to modesty.

Q: Modesty?

A: That’s right. The first variant of shameful/scamful actually meant “modest”. While shameless/scamless meant “immodest” – a meaning that endures today.

Q: So they did start out as opposites?

A: They did. However, by the 1400s, “shameful” ditched the idea of modesty and went “all in” on being synonymous with “disgraceful” or causing shame.

Q: Territory that “shameless” was already covering?

A: Sort of. There are some differences between the two – in particular, it’s about who feels the shame.

Q: William H Macy?

A: No, not him. “Shame” itself is a tricky concept – kind of a deeper feeling of “guilt”. Shame is seeing ourselves as a bad person. If you do something bad, you might feel shame.

Q: Okay.

A: “Shameful” is typically used to describe actions that are bad and cause shame. For example: “Her comments about the boss were shameful”.

Q: Ooooh juicy gossip! What did she say about the boss?

A: That’s not important. The main point is that they were bad.

Q: I wonder if HR will get involved…

A: It’s just an example! Anyway, “shameless” is where things get interesting.

Q: Because of William H Macy?

A: No, not because of him. You see, society expects us to feel shame for doing something bad. And that’s why a lack of shame is viewed in a similar way to feeling it. For example: “It was a shameless disregard for company policy”.

Q: Oh, now I just NEED to know what she did.

A: Focus.

Q: Okay sure. But wouldn’t “shameful disregard for policy” work equally?

A: It could, but note the carelessness is absent in that version. As we said, it’s all about owning the shame. Who is more dangerous? A criminal that feels shame or one that does not?

Q: It’s a trick question – they’re both dangerous!

A: Okay true. But that’s where the subtle difference in usage is important. “Shameful” shows off how bad something is, while “shameless” is about refusing to feel bad.

Q: Same same but different.

A: Yeah. And it’s why there is a similar tone in the phrases “have you no shame?” and “shame on you!” The outrage of someone feeling no shame (“shameless”) is viewed as similar to something described as “shameful”.

Q: What about someone who was “filled with shame”?

A: That’s where the sense of guilt and remorse comes back into it. In that case, the adjective you’d want is “ashamed”.

Q: Any other fun facts?

A: Actually, yes. The word “shend” was once synonymous with shame and disgrace – it came from Old English “scand”. While “shend” has long since died out, its word origin gave us “scandal”.

Q: Oh, do you mean the US political thriller series starring William H Macy?

A: No. And he actually isn’t in that series.

Q: That’s a crying shame. Such an underrated actor.

A: The H stands for Hall.

Q: Well let’s wrap up this hall of shame with a recap. “Shameful” and “shameless” may be opposites yet both share negative connotations thanks to society. 

A: Or as Steve from Shameless would say, “90% of this world’s problems are caused by little words that come in pairs”…

Do you have a question you’d like us to explore? Email it to us today!

Browse posts by category
Browse posts by category

Courses starting soon

About us

The Australian Writers’ Centre offers courses in creative writing, freelance writing, business writing, blogging and much more. Our practical and industry-proven courses will help you gain confidence and meet your goals faster!

Contact us

Phone: (02) 9929 0088 Email: courses@writerscentre.com.au Head office: Suite 3,
55 Lavender Street, Milsons Point NSW 2061

© 2021 Australian Writers' Centre | FAQs | Terms, conditions & privacy policy

GET OUR FREE WEEKLY NEWSLETTER – WITH WRITING TIPS, COMPETITIONS AND MORE! YES PLEASE!

Back to top ↑
×

Nice one! You've added this to your cart